| 2021 Golf All-Stars | |
| First Team | |
| Wyatt Smith | Dirigo |
| Carter O'Connell | Monmouth |
| Kyle Clavet | Monmouth |
| Matthew Fenlason | Spruce Mtn. |
| Alex Grimaldi | Spruce Mtn. |
| Cam Hurd | Winthrop |
| Averi Beaudoin | Monmouth |
| Reese Beaudoin | Monmouth |
| Mia Luce | Monmouth |
| Kasey Kaplan | Monmouth |
| Second Team | |
| Keegan Foreman | Dirigo |
| Landon Nichols | Madison |
| Jamison Bergeron | Oak Hill |
| Tylere Spugnardi | Spruce Mtn. |
| Colton Baird | Winthrop |
| Nate Hachey | Winthrop |
| Player(s) of the Year | |
| Wyatt Smith | Dirigo |
| Averi Beaudoin | Monmouth |
| Coach of the Year | |
| Dianne Fenlason | Spruce Mtn. |
| Honorable Mention | |
| Egan Roy | Mtn. Valley |
| Ian Cameron | Mtn. Valley |
| Riley Inch | Monmouth |
| Jayce Corgan | Winthrop |
| Daxtyn Poisson | Spruce Mtn. |
| Bryce Marston | Spruce Mtn. |